Car insurance: comprehensive vs third party, fire and theft

Prices can vary a lot between levels of car insurance cover, and so can what you are protected against. This guide explains the differences to help you decide.

By Vuskoo16 de noviembre de 20262 min read
Car insurance: comprehensive vs third party, fire and theft

In the UK there are three main levels of car insurance cover. Each one protects you against different risks, and the price gap between them is not always what you would expect. Here is how they compare.

Third party only

Third party only cover pays for damage or injury you cause to other people, their vehicles and their property. It does not cover damage to your own car. It is the minimum level of cover you need by law to drive on UK roads.

It is usually only worth considering for older cars with a low market value. Even then, get quotes for higher levels of cover too, because third party only is not always the lower-priced option.

Third party, fire and theft

This includes everything in third party only cover, and also covers your car if it is stolen or damaged by fire. Some policies include extras such as windscreen cover or breakdown assistance, but these vary between insurers, so check the policy details.

It can suit drivers with a car of moderate value who want protection against theft and fire but are prepared to pay for accident damage to their own car themselves.

Comprehensive

Comprehensive cover is the highest level of protection. As well as third party, fire and theft cover, it pays for damage to your own car after an accident, even if you were at fault. Many policies also include windscreen cover and personal belongings as standard.

Examples of comprehensive policies available include:

  • Hastings Direct Comprehensive: from £35/mo
  • Direct Line Comprehensive Car Insurance: from £38/mo
  • Admiral Comprehensive Car Insurance: from £42/mo

Other car insurers to compare include Churchill, LV=, M&S Insurance and, for drivers over 50, Saga. Your actual price will depend on your car, your driving history, where you live and other factors.

How your excess affects the price

The excess is the amount you pay towards each claim. Most policies have a compulsory excess set by the insurer, and you can usually add a voluntary excess on top. Choosing a higher voluntary excess can lower your premium while keeping comprehensive cover.

Only choose an excess you could afford to pay if you needed to make a claim, as you will have to pay the full combined amount before the insurer covers the rest.

How to decide

  • Think about what your car is worth and whether you could afford to repair or replace it yourself.
  • Compare quotes for all three levels of cover, not just the one you expect to be lowest.
  • Check what each policy includes as standard, such as windscreen cover, a courtesy car or breakdown assistance.
  • Look at the total excess, not only the monthly or annual price.

Photo: StockSnap / Pixabay

Subscribe to our newsletter

The best deals and money-saving tips, straight to your inbox. No spam.