Energy

Fixed monthly Direct Debit for energy: how it works, what happens at the annual review and when it suits you

A fixed monthly Direct Debit spreads your estimated yearly energy cost into equal payments, then your supplier checks it against your real usage. Here is how the amount is worked out, what to check and how it compares with fixed and variable tariffs.

By Vuskoo · · 7 min read

Fixed monthly Direct Debit for energy: how it works, what happens at the annual review and when it suits you
In this article
  1. How a fixed monthly Direct Debit works
  2. What happens at the review
  3. What to check before you agree
  4. Fixed Direct Debit, fixed tariff or variable tariff: the differences
  5. When a fixed monthly Direct Debit suits you
  6. Frequently asked questions

Paying for energy by fixed monthly Direct Debit means you pay the same amount each month, based on how much electricity (and gas, if you have it) your supplier expects you to use over a year. It does not mean your energy is unlimited. Your supplier keeps track of what you have paid against what you have actually used, and your account builds up credit or falls into debit. The payment is then reviewed, usually once a year or if the balance drifts a long way. It works best if your usage is fairly steady and you like predictable bills, but it is worth checking how the amount is calculated and what happens if your usage changes.

How a fixed monthly Direct Debit works

The idea is simple: instead of paying larger bills in winter and smaller ones in summer, your estimated yearly cost is split into twelve equal payments. You pay the same each month, and your account balance absorbs the difference between expensive and cheaper months. In summer you will often build up credit, which is then used up over the winter.

The Direct Debit is only a way of paying. Behind it there is still a unit rate per kWh and a daily standing charge, as with any tariff. Your meter keeps recording what you really use, and that is what your bill is based on in the end.

How the monthly amount is calculated

In general, suppliers work it out like this:

  1. Estimated annual consumption: the supplier uses your past twelve months of usage, or a typical estimate if there is no history, for example when you move into a new home.
  2. Standing charge: the daily charge is added, which you pay whether or not you use any energy.
  3. Tariff rates: the unit rates of your tariff are applied, along with VAT.
  4. Spreading the cost: the estimated yearly cost is divided into monthly payments, sometimes adjusted to take account of any existing credit or debt on your account.

If the starting estimate is wrong, the monthly payment will be wrong too. Before you agree to an amount, compare the annual consumption figure your supplier uses with the figures on your previous bills or annual statement.

What happens at the review

At the review, your supplier compares what you have paid with the actual cost of the energy you used, based on your meter readings. There are three possible outcomes:

  • You used less than expected: your account is in credit. Depending on your supplier, the credit may be kept on the account, used to lower future payments or refunded. You can usually ask for a refund of credit, so check how your supplier handles this.
  • You used about what was expected: there is little or no change.
  • You used more: your account is in debit. You may be asked to pay the shortfall, or it may be added to your monthly payments for the coming year, which will then go up.

When you switch supplier or move home, a final bill is produced. If you have used more than you paid, you will still owe the difference; if you are in credit, your old supplier should refund it.

How often the payment is reviewed

Many suppliers review payments once a year, but some do so more often, especially if they see a large difference between payments and usage or if energy prices change. Check how often your supplier reviews payments, whether they tell you before changing the amount and whether you can ask for a change yourself when your habits change, for example after getting a heat pump or an electric vehicle charger.

Why meter readings matter

Reviews are only as accurate as the readings behind them. If you have a smart meter that sends readings automatically, check that it is working in smart mode. If not, submit regular readings so your bills are not based on estimates.

What to check before you agree

Two offers with similar monthly payments can end up costing quite different amounts over a year. These are the points worth checking:

  • Estimated annual consumption: the kWh figure the payment is based on. It should be close to what you really use.
  • Unit rates and standing charges: the monthly payment matters less than the rates behind it.
  • Type of tariff: whether prices are fixed for a set period or can change, and how you will be told about changes.
  • Handling of credit: whether credit is refunded automatically, on request or kept on the account.
  • Exit fees: variable tariffs usually have none, but fixed tariffs may charge a fee if you leave early. Check the terms, including whether you can switch without a fee near the end of the fixed period.
  • Payment method: some tariffs are only available with Direct Debit, while prepayment works differently, as you pay for energy before you use it.
  • Extras: add-ons such as boiler cover bundled into your payment raise the total even if you never use them.

Fixed Direct Debit, fixed tariff or variable tariff: the differences

People often confuse a fixed monthly payment with a fixed tariff, but they are not the same. With a fixed Direct Debit, the monthly payment is what stays the same. With a fixed tariff, the unit rates and standing charges are what stay the same for a set period, and what you owe still depends on how much you use. With a standard variable tariff, prices can change, usually in line with the energy price cap set by Ofgem. You can combine these: many households pay a fixed monthly Direct Debit on either a fixed or a variable tariff.

On this page you will see variable and flexible tariffs such as Octopus Energy Flexible Tariff, So Energy Flex and British Gas Standard Variable; fixed tariffs such as E.ON Next Fixed 12-Month and OVO Energy 1-Year Fix; smart and electric vehicle tariffs such as EDF Smart Tariff and E.ON Next Drive Smart; and prepayment with Utilita Pay As You Go. Before you decide, check in each tariff's terms what is actually fixed and for how long.

How to compare using your own figures

  1. Gather your bills or annual statement for the past twelve months and note your total usage in kWh for electricity and gas.
  2. Using each tariff's unit rates and standing charges, work out the yearly cost for that usage.
  3. If you are offered a monthly payment, multiply it by twelve and check which annual consumption figure it is based on.
  4. For variable tariffs, remember that prices can change during the year, so your estimate is only a guide.
  5. Compare yearly totals, not the payment for a single month.

A lower monthly payment does not mean a lower cost. If it is based on an underestimate, you will simply build up debt that has to be paid later.

When a fixed monthly Direct Debit suits you

It tends to make sense if:

  • Your usage is similar from year to year and you have a billing history.
  • You prefer to avoid large bills in winter and want to plan your budget.
  • You are happy for credit to build up in summer to cover colder months.

It may suit you less if:

  • Your habits are about to change: working from home, more people in the household, a heat pump or an electric vehicle.
  • You have solar panels and the energy you take from the grid varies a lot by season.
  • You would rather pay for exactly what you use each month, for example through variable Direct Debit or by paying on receipt of a bill, where available.

Frequently asked questions

Does a fixed monthly payment mean unlimited energy?

No. The payment is based on estimated usage. If you use more, your account goes into debit and the difference is collected later or added to future payments.

Is VAT included in the monthly payment?

Usually, yes. Household energy bills include VAT, and your monthly payment is normally calculated on prices including VAT. Check your bill or statement to confirm.

Can I switch supplier while paying by fixed Direct Debit?

Yes. The payment method does not stop you switching. Check whether your tariff has exit fees, and expect a final bill: you will pay any debit or receive back any credit.

What should I do if my payment goes up a lot after a review?

Check that your bills are based on real meter readings rather than estimates, compare the new consumption figure with your current habits and ask your supplier how the new amount was calculated. If you think it is too high, you can ask them to review it.

Is a fixed Direct Debit the same as a fixed tariff?

No. A fixed Direct Debit keeps your monthly payment the same. A fixed tariff keeps your prices the same for a set period, but what you owe still depends on how much energy you use.

Compare energyReal deals with the final price, checked every day.
See deals

← Back to the blog

Subscribe to our newsletter

The best deals and money-saving tips, straight to your inbox. No spam.